Creamy Kohl Eye Pencil

Raccoon City

While I understand this is meant for smoky look, the product moves all over. It smudges like crazy and runs down to my cheeks. Any type of lining I do with this will get smudges within minutes even after applying setting products. I wish I could give it 0 stars.

Faded and ran all over eyelid within hours

I wanted to love this because the brown was a rich color and promised to be a long wear eyeliner. But within hours the inner half of my lid had faded and the outer half was all over my eyelid. I tried again with an eye primer and it still faded to nothing within a couple of hours. I’ve had better results with drugstore brands.

Really good, it stays in waterline & doesn’t smudge at all. And it’s very pigmented! I recommend 😁

Smooth and long lasting

Lasts a very long time, minimal smudging, can still be moved a little if you wipe it away right after applying which I like for easy correction. Color is very pigmented and goes on so smooth. The photo is me after wearing the eyeliner for 10+ hours.

Terrible product makes smudges

Terrible eyeliner. Smudges and makes a person look like a raccoon

Easy application. Creamy texture

Love it. Super thin pencil, easy application and super dark. Stays on a while.

Super creamy! A must!

This formula is very creamy!!! If you are doing waterline this is perfect! Glides every easily onto your eye!!!

I have been searching for a waterproof eyeliner that doesn’t smudge when I tight line, and unfortunately I am still on the hunt. I’m sure it would be a good eyeliner for a smoky eye, but it’s tough to blend out. I get a black rim on my lower lash line immediately after I apply. It smudges down into my lower lash line after that:(

Works best on a day out in colder weather

It works well. It mostly stays in place even without primer, but will smudge if the temperature is too hot.

Not the same

I had high hopes for this liner. The previous one I had was great, but this batch that was restocked isn't as good. The pigment is great, but the staying power is poor. After a few hours of wear I noticed smudges at the outer corners of my eyes as well as flaking. Going to return.

Started falling apart after second use.

Pieces of product kept breaking off and then fell out of casing entirely. Simply unuseable. Very disappointing.

Smudges

Super pigmented, goes on easily but smudges soooo much. I don't understand all these reviews that say it doesn't. I don't have oily skin and shortly after application it's a mess.