24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil

Good but they’ve changed the pencil

I love this pencil and have used for years but they’ve changed the pencil itself. When I first opened the package the tip immediately fell off. When I went to sharpen it was rough and difficult to sharpen, almost like it’s not supposed to be sharpened, but it is. The tip won’t stay sharp.

Pretty Good!

This eyeliner Does Last All day thats for sure!! Only thing is I wish it was a bit creamier for more versatile uses!! But it does do the job! Also not sure if I’m allergic to it or not. So be careful if you’re also sensitive skinned like me!

My only eyeliner!

Best eyeliner for my water line, the only one that doesn’t flake off onto my contacts… I wish it was available in more shades is my only complaint..

My absolute favorite

I love how the color develops quickly and looks really good for big eyes

Terrible!

Waste of money! A struggle to get any color to show up no staying power whatsoever. This isn’t even good enough for the skin around the eye let alone the waterline.

A must have

This works wonders and lasts all day whenever I’m wearing it. It’s one of my makeup staples and I’m not exactly sure why it has so many bad reviews on the app, for someone who loves lining the upper and lower waterline in black it’s amazing.

Great pigmented but smudge after awhile

Easy to glide , great pigmented but it doesn’t stay even 2 hours on waterline. It started smudging after a while.

not worth it

i dont like it, when i tried to apply it, the lead kept breaking off even though i was gently trying to apply it. application looked messy, doesn’t happen with other waterline pencils.

I have used this particular eye pencil consistently, over the few years, each one seems a little less substantial and does not last nearly as long. I will continue to use this, but the quality has changed and that's disappointing. I still recommend it, but be aware that it doesn't sharpen well and does not last as long as it should. (IMHO)

I love this waterline eyeliner. Goes on well and easily. Some say it doesn’t last but the waterline is moist so any eyeliner won’t last superrr long in the waterline. It’s great!!

its got on me in a chokehold

I just jumped off a 45-foot waterfall in the Puerto Rican rainforest. I swam up, took a flick, and saw that my eyeliner was still KILLING IT so I HAD to write a review. Even sweating like a pig my eyes are always looking snatched. Unfortunately, a good sob will do the trick of rubbing it off. But you know what, you shouldn't be crying anyway when you look that good. It also doesn't do that thing that some pencils do where they get short and suddenly the crayon is wobbling around in the wooden casing.

Heavy-duty and Smooth

Thee best waterline pencil. Long-lasting and sweat/waterproof as advertised! Holds up through these humid Hawaiian summers, busy mom-life and late night punk shows!! No need to reapply yet removes easily at the end of the day. I'd recommend KatVonD's waterline pencil as an alternative if this is ever "out of stock".